News, Analysis, Trends, Management Innovations for
Clinical Laboratories and Pathology Groups

Hosted by Robert Michel

News, Analysis, Trends, Management Innovations for
Clinical Laboratories and Pathology Groups

Hosted by Robert Michel
Sign In

Minnesota Hospitals in Financial Crisis as State’s Healthcare Systems Record Hundreds of Millions of Dollars in Losses

Nationwide, hospital losses are in the billions of dollars, which affects access to medical care including clinical laboratory testing

Hospitals and health systems across the United States continue to report substantial financial losses. At some institutions, this might severely restrict access to physicians and clinical laboratory testing for patients in those areas. The latest state to announce its hospitals were in trouble is Minnesota. The Minnesota Hospital Association (MHA) announced its hospitals are in “financial crisis” revealing that the state’s health systems experience hundreds of millions of dollars in operating losses annually.

The MHA stated that two out of three surveyed hospitals in Minnesota reported losing money in the cumulative amount of more than $400 million during the first half of 2023, KARE 11 reported. The MHA surveyed more than 70 health system members which represented facilities of all sizes and in all geographical regions of the state.

Rahul Koranne, MD, President and CEO of MHA told KARE 11 that part of the problem is that a larger proportion of patients rely on federal programs such as Medicare and Medicaid to pay hospital costs. Those programs provide lower reimbursement rates when compared to private insurers. In some facilities, almost 75% of patients are on one of these government programs. 

“Those reimbursements, or payments, are fixed. So, we can’t raise prices. These two programs are paying significantly below the cost of providing care to our patients,” he noted. “So, if you have 70% of your patients covered by these governmental programs, we can’t raise prices, and they’re paying you below the cost of care—that’s what causes [the problem].”

He went on to state that workforce staffing represents a significant challenge for hospitals and urged the state legislature to address the needs of health professionals and facilities. 

“We need to really resource it in this upcoming session and many sessions to come, so that we can have workers and staff we need,” Koranne said. “If we don’t have the money, and if we don’t have the workers, we will not be providing care and that would be sad.”

Rahul Koranne, MD

“This is a pretty grave state and, I would say, quite a crisis,” Rahul Koranne, MD (above), President and CEO of the Minnesota Hospital Association, told KARE 11. “Our not-for-profit hospitals and healthcare systems are hanging dangerously from this cliff and they’re getting tired.” Access to medical laboratory testing can be greatly affected by hospital financial losses. (Photo copyright: Twin Cities Business.)

Other US Healthcare Systems in Crisis as Well

Minnesota is not the only state with healthcare systems in financial crisis. Last year, the Washington State Hospital Association (WSHA) announced that hospitals in that state reported cumulative losses of $2 billion for 2022. Cassie Sauer, President and CEO of WSHA told the media that the massive deficits are “clear and incredibly concerning” to the state’s healthcare leaders.

In “Hospitals, Pharmacies Struggle to Be Profitable,” we reported that the WSHA survey determined that the state’s hospitals suffered collective operating losses of $750 million during the first six months of 2023.

“The financial losses that our hospitals are experiencing continue to be enormous,” Sauer told The Seattle Times. “Revenues simply are not keeping up with rapidly escalating costs. It’s most concerning as these large losses are putting patient care at risk in many communities across the state.”

The WSHA findings were based on a survey of 81 acute-care hospitals that represented about 98% of the state’s hospital beds. Of those facilities, 69 reported losing money mostly due to rising costs for supplies, labor, and other expenses as well as the need for longer hospital stays due to more complicated care and a larger percentage of patients on government programs, which offer lower reimbursement rates for care. 

“When hospitals are not financially viable and over time sustain heavy losses, you must either increase revenue or reduce healthcare services,” Chelene Whiteaker, Senior Vice President, Government Affairs at WSHA, told The Seattle Times. “Reducing healthcare services is an option nobody wants on the table. So, that leaves increasing revenues.”

Graphic

The graphic above from the Center for Healthcare Quality and Payment Reform (CHQPR) shows the number and location of rural hospitals in America that are at “immediate” risk of closure. The number of hospitals simply “at risk” of closure is substantially higher. Patients who depend on these hospitals would lose access to critical healthcare services including clinical laboratory testing. (Graphic copyright: Center for Healthcare Quality and Payment Reform.)

Becker’s Hospital Review reported last year that many hospitals across the country reported substantial losses in 2022. Three of the hospital systems in that article reported losses in the billions. They were:

In addition, Becker’s noted that five healthcare systems reported encountering losses over half a billion dollars in 2022. They include:

Critical Services Are Being Cut

In another article, Becker’s reported that 72 hospitals across the US closed departments or ended services in 2023. These cuts included the shuttering of health and urgent care clinics, the closure of outpatient cancer and pulmonary clinics, the reduction of certain surgical services and behavioral health services, and the ending of home healthcare services.

Some states are taking measures to prevent further hospital closures. But is it too late? In “California Doles Out $300 Million in No-Interest Loans to Save its Financially Struggling Hospitals,” The Dark Report’s sister publication Dark Daily covered how that state had launched an interest-free loan program to ensure local communities have access to community hospitals, their physicians, and clinical laboratories. No report on how many hospitals have been temporarily saved from closing thanks to this program.

If US hospitals continue to lose money at this rate, access to critical care—including clinical laboratory and anatomic pathology services—could be further restricted and facilities closed. These actions may also result in increased staff layoffs and have an even greater effect on patient care in Minnesota, Washington State, and throughout the US.

—JP Schlingman

Related Information:

Minnesota Hospital Association CEO Says the State’s Hospitals are in a Financial ‘Crisis’

Minnesota Hospitals and Health Systems Lose Hundreds of Millions as Revenues Fall and Inflation Hikes Labor and Other Costs

A Hard Look at Minnesota Hospital Finances

WA Hospitals Lost $2 Billion in 2022. A Plan to Up Medicaid Rates Could Help

72 Hospitals Closing Departments or Ending Services

What’s Up with Hospital Finances?

What’s Behind Losses at Large Nonprofit Health Systems?

20 Health Systems Reporting Losses in 2022

CHQPR Report: Rural Hospitals at Risk Of Closing

More Than 30% of Rural Hospitals Are at Risk of Closure, Report Warns

California Doles Out $300 Million in No-Interest Loans to Save its Financially Struggling

HospitalsHospitals, Pharmacies Struggle to Be Profitable

Military’s Fifth Health System Market Cuts Costs by Keeping Pathology Services ‘On-base’

Even US military clinical laboratories strive to cut costs, protect quality, and improve outcomes

Defense Health Agency (DHA), a part of the federal Department of Defense (DOD), recently launched a plan to consolidate healthcare facilities within certain geographical regions and to unify and integrate the military’s clinical laboratory operations in those areas. The goal is to streamline efficiencies and lower costs while maintaining quality lab testing services. 

The DOD operates a nationwide network of medical treatment facilities (MTFs) that include state-of-the-art clinical and anatomic pathology laboratories serving military personnel and their families. These military labs face the same issues of cost, efficiency, and outcomes as do civilian clinical laboratories throughout the United States.

To address those challenges and bring together clinical laboratory services in specific regions, the DHA established the Tidewater Market in April of 2021 to serve select US Air Force, Army, and Navy MTFs in the Washington DC metro area, central North Carolina, Jacksonville, and coastal Mississippi.

Tidewater is the fifth Military Health System (MHS) market created to manage MTFs as they transition into the DHA.

Health.mil—a website maintained by the MHS as an informational resource for those it serves—describes the MHS as “one of America’s largest and most complex healthcare institutions, and the world’s preeminent military healthcare delivery operation.

“Our MHS saves lives on the battlefield, combats infectious disease around the world, and is responsible for providing health services through both direct care [at military hospitals and clinics known as ‘military treatment facilities’] and private sector care to approximately 9.6 million beneficiaries, composed of uniformed service members, military retirees, and family members,” Health.mil notes.

With 9.6 million beneficiaries, MHS is one of the largest healthcare service organizations operating in the United States.

Navy Rear Admiral Darin Via, MD

“The establishment of this market provides a true opportunity to optimize healthcare for our beneficiaries by focusing on outcomes and access across the Tidewater market,” said Navy Rear Admiral Darin Via, MD, Tidewater market manager, in an MHS/DHA news release. “It also allows us to work towards standardization of processes, creating an easier environment for our patients to navigate within.” (Photo copyright: US Navy.)

Finding Efficiencies, Optimizing Clinical Laboratory Processes and Services

In an article outlining the Tidewater Market clinical laboratory initiative, Health.mil noted that “A market is a group of MTFs in one geographic area working together with its TRICARE partners, Veterans Affairs hospitals, other federal healthcare organizations, private sector teaching hospitals and medical universities, as well as other healthcare partners. Markets operate as a system to support the sharing of patients, staff, budget, and other functions across facilities to improve readiness and the delivery and coordination of health services.”

The Tidewater Market provides integrated, affordable, high-quality healthcare services to active-duty service members, military retirees, reservists and national guardsmen, and their families. The market currently serves more than 390,000 beneficiaries.

In 2022, the Tidewater Market Laboratory/Pathology Integration Working Group was created to optimize services while reducing costs within the market. The group was created by US Navy Captain Stacie Milavec, who has more than 23 years of experience in military medicine.

Milavec is a clinical laboratory scientist certified through the American Society for Clinical Pathology (ASCP) and American Medical Technologists (AMT). She served on the board of directors for the Society of American Federal Medical Laboratory Scientists (SAFMLS) and is a member of the American College of Healthcare Executives (ACHE) and American Society for Clinical Laboratory Science (ASCLS).

“One of DHA’s goals with setting up a market structure is to find efficiencies and optimize and standardize processes and services wherever possible,” Milavec said in an MHS/DHA news release. “We’ve been able to do exactly that by collaborating within our working group.”

Resource Sharing between Military Clinical Laboratories

The MTFs that are geographically close to each other helped expedite turnaround times for testing results. By working together, they saved the Tidewater Market an estimated $80,000 during fiscal year 2022.

One of the methods they used to streamline testing and lower costs was to allow resource sharing between facilities within the market. For example, the full-service clinical laboratory located at the Naval Medical Center Portsmouth (NMCP) began performing head and neck pathology cases, breast biopsies, and PAP testing for some of the other facilities within the Tidewater Market. These services were previously performed by other means and in some cases were sent to commercially-contracted clinical laboratories for analysis at a high cost.

The NMCP also took on Human Papilloma Virus (HPV) testing for all MTFs within the market. 

In February of 2023, NMCP began taking on additional clinical chemistry tests from the 633rd Medical Group at Joint Base Langley-Eustis located in Hampton, Virginia. Prior to that collaboration, those tests were sent out to contracted labs off-base for analysis. 

“[Through collaboration between the MTFs] we’ve been able to successfully transition civilian marketplace send-out testing back into the military market by utilizing market resources,” said pathologist US Air Force Captain Dianna Chormanski, MD, Laboratory Medical Director with the 633rd Medical Group at Joint Base Langley-Eustis, in the press release. “I’m a big fan of cooperation and working together, and that’s what a market should be.”

The DHA established the market-based structure as part of the National Defense Authorization Act for Fiscal Year 2017. It’s an example of regional laboratory consolidation within one region of the US where a common effort brought together clinical laboratories operating on military bases of different services. The military’s goal was a unified, integrated medical laboratory operation that could deliver targeted cost savings while maintaining quality lab testing services. It appears to be successful.   

—JP Schlingman

Related Information:

Tidewater Market Saves by Integrating and Optimizing Pathology Services

Tidewater Set to Become Fifth Military Health System Market

New Tidewater Market Strengthens DOD’s Medical Readiness, Promises Better Patient Experience

Pandemic Spotlights the Vital Role of Military Lab Workers

;