Severe Lack of Volunteers for Clinical Laboratory Studies Has US Alzheimer’s Researchers Employing Innovative Methods to Recruit Participants
Low interest and a lack of diversity among study participants hinders research into one of America’s most fatal and costly chronic diseases
Finding enough people to participate in clinical laboratory trials for Alzheimer’s disease can be a daunting task for researchers. The shortage of participants has compelled scientists to develop innovative ways to locate volunteers for their studies. That includes “Swab-a-Palooza” events to make it easy for individuals to provide samples for this research and get speedy feedback about their ApoE.
“It’s all about recruitment now,” Stephen Salloway, MD, Director of Neurology and the Memory and Aging Program at Butler Hospital in Providence, R.I., and Professor of Clinical Neurosciences and Psychiatry at Brown Medical School, said in an article on the Biomedical Research Forum (BRF) website.
Some researchers are hunting online and offering free genetic testing to interested individuals to ensure they obtain the number of participants needed for their trials. Both the Alzheimer’s Prevention Registry (APR) and the Brain Health Registry (BHR) are using the Internet to compile listings of suitable participants.
The APR is dedicated to uniting Alzheimer’s researchers with individuals interested in participating in clinical trials. The Phoenix-based non-profit organization also educates the public on Alzheimer’s and prevention of the disease. The Brain Health Registry is a web-based research study led by medical researchers at the University of California, San Francisco. Participants complete online questionnaires and tests that provide researchers with information regarding an individual’s health, lifestyle, and cognitive function. The collected data is used to create a listing of potential participants for Alzheimer’s studies.
Using Genetic Testing to Recruit Alzheimer’s Study Participants
GeneMatch is a program led by the Banner Alzheimer’s Institute in the Phoenix area that is part of the APR. The purpose of this national program is to recruit participants for research on Alzheimer’s disease by using genetic testing to match qualified volunteers with research studies. According to their website, 80% of research studies on the disease aren’t completed on time due to a lack of volunteers.
Anyone can register to be part of GeneMatch as long as they live in the United States and are between the ages of 55 and 75. In addition, participants cannot have a diagnosis of cognitive impairment, Alzheimer’s, or dementia.
“We hold local swabbing parties, where the GeneMatch sign-up rate is 95%,” Pierre Tariot, MD, Internal Medicine and Psychiatry, and Director of Banner Alzheimer’s Institute, said in the BRF article. “Jeffrey Cummings calls them Swab-a-Paloozas.”
GeneMatch screens individuals for the Apolipoprotein E (ApoE) and the ApoE-e4 allele which increases the risk for Alzheimer’s disease and is associated with earlier onset of memory loss and other symptoms. At this time, it is not known how this allele is related to the risk of getting the disease, but researchers have discovered the brain tissue of affected individuals have an increased number of protein clumps called amyloid plaques. A buildup of these plaques may lead to the death of neurons and the presence of Alzheimer’s symptoms.
“I spend a lot of time in my community doing outreach. People are very interested and receptive,” said Salloway, who recently hosted a swabbing party for GeneMatch. “At events, I ask everyone to tell five other people about what they learned, and to host swabbing parties themselves.”
The DNA samples obtained by GeneMatch are analyzed by a Clinical Laboratory Improvement Amendments (CLIA) certified laboratory. Over the past two years, GeneMatch has tested over 45,000 individuals for the ApoE-e4 allele and were able to identify 1,000 homozygote and 9,000 heterozygote carriers.
Lack of Diversity Among Study Participants
A paper published in September 2017 by Jeffrey Cummings, MD, Director of the Cleveland Clinic Lou Ruvo Center for Brain Health in Las Vegas, estimated the number of participants currently needed for Alzheimer’s research is over 55,000. Clinical trials for Alzheimer’s need volunteers who have little or no symptoms of the illness and locating such interested individuals can be complicated.
Additional obstacles that face Alzheimer’s researchers are the lack of diversity among volunteers for their studies. The participants in GeneMatch are 78% female and there is little representation of African-American and Latino minorities.
“It’s not easy to get healthy individuals to join, and those who do are predominantly highly educated, white, and female,” Jessica Langbaum, PhD, Principal Scientist at Banner Alzheimer’s Institute, said in the BRF article. “That’s okay if the women are the health-info gatherers and send their men for trials, but it will be a problem if we cannot get men into studies.”
Delivering ApoE Genotype Results at Events
Technology that could help locate participants for Alzheimer’s research at open “Swab-a-Palooza” events include a small ApoE analyzer called the Spartan Cube. The small molecular diagnostic device, manufactured by Ottawa-based Spartan Bioscience, Inc., can deliver an ApoE genotype result in less than an hour. The gadget is perfect for outreach gatherings, as people can learn their ApoE genotype while at an event. At this time, the Spartan Cube is used only for research purposes and is not CLIA approved.
The paper by Cummings was a topic of discussion at the Clinical Trials on Alzheimer’s Disease (CTAD), which was held in November in Boston. The CTAD is an annual conference for Alzheimer’s disease researchers to meet and share information about the disease with each other. The 11th CTAD conference will take place in Barcelona, Spain, in October of this year.
More than five million people are living with Alzheimer’s disease in the United States and this number could reach 16 million by 2050, according to the Alzheimer’s Association. It is the sixth leading cause of death in the US and cost the nation $259 billion in 2017. It’s estimated that the costs associated with the disease could reach $1.1 trillion by 2050, which makes finding volunteers for research studies an important endeavor.